Our cotton Caddy Towel weighs 8.3 ounces. Our microfiber towel weighs 11.2. People email me every week asking which one to buy. Same large size towel, 22" x 44" inches. Here's how they stack up against one another.
Two paths, Same Result
Golfers wet their towel and love a towel that can stay wet all round, so I'll start with the number everyone wants. Soak each towel all the way, hold it up until it stops dripping, and weigh it again. The cotton towel holds somewhere around 30 to 40 ounces of water. The microfiber holds 55 to 75. Call it a quart versus two quarts.
Water each towel holds when fully soaked
Cotton Caddy Towel (8.3 oz dry)
Premium Microfiber Towel (11.2 oz dry)
Why the gap? Cotton pulls water into the fiber itself. The fiber swells.
Polyester doesn't do that. A microfiber towel holds water in the tiny spaces between fibers that are split thinner than silk. There are millions of those spaces, so it adds up fast. The deep waffle pattern adds little pockets on top of that. And per square inch, the microfiber has about 35 percent more fabric packed in. That's where the extra 3 ounces come from.
Now the catch.
That two-quart number is a dripping towel. Wring it hard and most of that water leaves, because it was only sitting between the fibers. Cotton won't give its water back. The water is inside the fiber and it stays there. So after a good wring, the gap is a lot smaller than two to one. Microfiber also dries faster. More surface, and the fibers themselves don't hold water. Cotton lets go slowly.
Weight matters here if you walk. A fully soaked microfiber towel is a 4 to 5 pound towel before you wring it. The cotton one is about 2 pounds lighter at the same point.
So both towels make it to 18 damp, just by different routes. The cotton hangs on to what it has. The microfiber starts with more.

Which one goes on your face?
This one isn't close. The cotton towel is the one you want on your skin.
Terry loops are soft, and they pull sweat into the fiber. That's why a cotton towel feels dry against your face even after you've used it a few times.
Microfiber grabs. If your hands are dry or you've got calluses from the range, you know the feeling. It's a little like dragging Velcro across your palm.
A waffle weave is also less plush than terry, which doesn't help.
So if you mostly use a towel on your hands and face, cotton is your towel.

Which golf towel cleans your grooves best?
For grooves, the microfiber waffle. The raised ridges and split fibers grab mud, wet sand and that green grass juice that lives on your wedge all summer.
The pockets in the weave trap the gunk, so you drag a lot less of it back across the clubface on the next wipe.
A cotton terry towel cleans a club fine. But the loops hold onto dirt and push it around, so you’ll be wiping a little longer. (Caked grooves still need a brush. No towel is a miracle--I personally use the miniG brush by Grooveit and hang it on my bag).
The waffle also has a slit, so you can hang it on a club and it stays put on the cart ride.
Our cotton Caddy Towel just drapes. People love how big it is, but “it falls off the cart” is the one gripe we hear. Fair enough. Golf has enough things falling off the cart already.

The Best Towel for Machine Washing
This is where the two towels really split.
Cotton doesn't care. Hot wash, bleach on the whites, any dryer setting. The 7 percent polyester in it is the base weave the loops hang from. That's what keeps the towel's shape over hundreds of washes. The trade is some lint, a little shrink on the first wash, and stains that sink in. A grass stain on cotton moves in and gets its mail delivered there.
Microfiber has rules. No fabric softener, ever. Softener coats the fibers and kills the one thing you bought the towel for. No bleach. Low heat in the dryer. And wash it with other synthetics, or it comes out wearing lint from your socks. Dirt lets go in the wash, so the white one comes back white. It won't fade and it won't shrink.
The one exception is sunscreen. Oils bond to polyester. A sunscreen smear will stick to the microfiber long after the cotton would have let it go.
TL:DR...
If you skipped to the bottom, this is the short version.
Get the cotton if the towel touches your skin more than your clubs. Same if you want stripes and don't want to think about laundry.
Get the microfiber if you play wet or sandy courses and want it hanging off a club instead of blowing into the woods. Also, promise me you'll skip the softener.
Or run one of each. Cotton for you, microfiber for the clubs. The clubs won't thank you, but they never do.
Both are on our golf towels page, and they're the same 22 by 44 size either way.

